mrbreau wrote:
Here is the link to the video. I went to the forum and searched for rickf* and followed my nose. Snk-snk
Link;
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... 9959&hl=enThe questions you are asking don't make any sense to me. I used the McCormick on a battery that wasn't any good to begin with so it failed. I have since found a place called the "Amish Country Store" located in Branson Missouri. It is cheap stuff there and the have an website. Buy it by the pound. I bought ten pounds because I plan on doing a LOT of batteries..............a lot of batteries!
I suggest you build/do the project and THEN ask questions. There will be tons of questions once you get going. And......don't be afraid to make mistakes. We ALL make mistakes. That is how WE learned what we know.
Warren
..
I agree with just start the project and ask questions later.
But let me try to clarify and try again to make some sense ...
The word Alum is ambiguous and tells us nothing.
There are at least a couple dozen different Alums (just guessing, maybe more)
The word Alum used with the word alkaline brings on further
confusion to this project without more information being known.
The instruction use Alum is like getting directions to
follow "the highway" but are not told what highway you are to follow.
If you just "start the project", dump the battery acid
and replace it with an acid solution, what's the point?
That *might* be the wrong point of the exercise.
I say might because I'm not sure what this solution should contain.
I know what words have been spoken, but know not what those
words meant to the people that spoke them (John Bendini or others)
Not knowing only promotes others to preform the same
needlessly incorrect actions.
When the question can be asked and an answer obtained,
then the question should be asked.
We have access to Peter Lindemann and I'm hoping he
can remove the ambiguous nature of being told to use
Alum.
I'm trying to get clarification of what is meant by the phase
"alkaline solution" or "convert acid to alkaline".
Alum by definition contains a alkali metal, but most of these
Alums from those I've looked at, create an acid solution and
not an alkaline solution.
Is the word alkaline use in reference to the alkali metal, which is only
a component of the Alum (making an acid solution)
or is the intent really to use an alkaline solution?
If I'm suppose to be using an Alum (acid solution) I would like
to know what components making up the Alum where selected
and why. Or that it just does not matter what Alum is used and why.
If I'm using an acid solution, why am I not using battery acid again?
If there's a reason, that reason most be a component of the Alum,
of which, there are over a couple dozen Alums at least. Which
component is the one we want to use?
If I'm going from Point A to Point B, I'd like to know that I'm on
Point A and not Point C before I start.
Some of these "failures" people are having might be due to starting
at Point C and not Point A.
Here are the components that can be in an Alum:
one from this list: aluminum, chromium, iron, manganese, cobalt, or titanium
and
one from this list: potassium, sodium, rubidium, caesium, silver. thallium or ammonium
That makes 42 (maybe) possible different Alums we could "Try".
Are you going to try all 42 ?
That's where I at and I'm sticking to it!!!